Talk:European XBRL Taxonomy Architecture V3.0

From XBRLWiki

Revision as of 13:28, 24 August 2013 (edit) Thierry.Declerck (Talk | contribs) (→Comment-03) ← Previous diff		Revision as of 13:39, 24 August 2013 (edit) Thierry.Declerck (Talk | contribs) (→Comments) Next diff →
Line 13:		Line 13:
	=== Comment-04 ===		=== Comment-04 ===
-	[IS]	+	[IS]d. In page 4, Introduction, general, paragraph fourth: “… authorities EBA and EIOPA for the electronic data…”, maybe “… authorities European Banking Authority (EBA) and European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority (EIOPA) for the electronic data…”.
	=== Comment-05 ===		=== Comment-05 ===
-	[IS]	+	[IS]f. In page 4, Target audience, first line: “EXTA is targeted at taxonomy authors. Initially organizations like EBA, EIOPA, ESMA, ECB etc.”. Maybe: “EXTA is targeted at taxonomy authors. Initially organizations like EBA, EIOPA, European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA), European Central Bank (ECB) etc.”.
	=== Comment-06 ===		=== Comment-06 ===
	[IS]		[IS]

---

Revision as of 13:39, 24 August 2013

Contents 1 Comments 1.1 Comment-01 1.2 Comment-02 1.3 Comment-03 1.4 Comment-04 1.5 Comment-05 1.6 Comment-06 1.7 Comment-07 1.8 Comment-08 1.9 Comment-09 1.10 Comment-10 1.11 Comment-11 1.12 Comment-12 1.13 Comment-13 1.14 Comment-14 1.15 Comment-15 1.16 Comment-16

Comments

Comment-01

[IS] a. In page 4, Introduction, general, paragraph first, line 4. The reference “[Bund13, p.3]” is referenced in the 47, and it is a “Internal Working Draft.”. If it is internal is not public, then the reference is not valid, because the general public cannot read.

Comment-02

[IS] b. In page 4, Introduction, general, paragraph first, line 7. I believe that “XBRL taxonomies are metadata specifications that provide a formal description of the data requirements to be used as data format in the European reporting process.” is a definition very formal, and it must be stand out, maybe with full stop.

Comment-03

[IS] c. In page 4, Introduction, general, paragraph second: “These pages are hosting the guidelines to an European XBRL Taxonomy Architecture (EXTA).”. You repeat the meaning of EXTA, maybe: “These pages are hosting as guidelines to EXTA.”.

Comment-04

[IS]d. In page 4, Introduction, general, paragraph fourth: “… authorities EBA and EIOPA for the electronic data…”, maybe “… authorities European Banking Authority (EBA) and European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority (EIOPA) for the electronic data…”.

Comment-05

[IS]f. In page 4, Target audience, first line: “EXTA is targeted at taxonomy authors. Initially organizations like EBA, EIOPA, ESMA, ECB etc.”. Maybe: “EXTA is targeted at taxonomy authors. Initially organizations like EBA, EIOPA, European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA), European Central Bank (ECB) etc.”.

Comment-06

[IS]

Comment-07

[IS]

Comment-08

[IS]

Comment-09

[IS]

Comment-10

[IS]

Comment-11

[IS]

Comment-12

[IS]

Comment-13

[IS]

Comment-14

[IS]

Comment-15

[IS]

Comment-16

[IS]