Talk:European Data Point Methodology V2.0

From XBRLWiki

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
Revision as of 14:10, 23 August 2013 (edit)
Thierry.Declerck (Talk | contribs)
(Comment-06)
← Previous diff
Revision as of 14:14, 23 August 2013 (edit)
Thierry.Declerck (Talk | contribs)
(Comment-07)
Next diff →
Line 19: Line 19:
=== Comment-07 === === Comment-07 ===
 +[TD] Comment by I. : h. In page 18, “4.6.2 RuleRelationship … The list of possible signs in a DataPointModel is not determined. Examples are: + (plus sign) or - (minus sign). ….”. Can have in a hierarchy “*” or “/”? I think: “4.6.2 RuleRelationship … The list of possible signs in a DataPointModel must be “+” or “-“. Examples are: + (plus sign) or - (minus sign). ….”.
 +
 +[TD] But I think this comment refers to a previous version of the document.
 +
=== Comment-08 === === Comment-08 ===
=== Comment-09 === === Comment-09 ===

Revision as of 14:14, 23 August 2013

Contents

Comments

Comment-01

[TD] Or better "Introduction" for section title? (comment "b" in the file Comments about CEN/TC XBRL)

Comment-02

[TD] Ignacio suggests "In the page 7, figure: Figure 1 —Structural Perspective, the cardinality of 1 is not necessary. [TD: I can not change the graphics]

Comment-03

[TD] Ignacio suggests here to repleace the sentence above the comment with: "In the DataPointModel a Hierarchy forms are sets of concepts of a domain (DefinedMembers) of a dimension (EnumerableDimension) arranged in a hierarchical disposition." Myself I note a problem with the expression: "a Hierarchy forms are sets" (should it bee "a Hierarchy forms sets ..."?

Comment-04

[TD] Suggestion by I. replace "A Module is a group of DataCubes that carry relevant identical semantics and may serve the reporting process" with "A Module is a group of DataPoints with its appropriate Dimensions and concepts of the dimension (DataCubes) ...."

Comment-05

[TD] Suggestion by I.: “4.3.10 Dimension, …. A Dimension can refer to a Domain. ….”. I would exchange by in “4.3.10 Dimension, …. A Dimension must refer to a Domain. ….”.

Comment-06

[TD] Comment by I. :“4.6 Hierarchical Perspective …. 1) When using multiple DimensionedElements on a single Dimension that has a Hierarchy in its DefinedMembers, the required math may not be possible to perform.”. I don’t understand. Only, it is possible to define a data point with only a member domain by dimension. Is this that you want to say?

Comment-07

[TD] Comment by I. : h. In page 18, “4.6.2 RuleRelationship … The list of possible signs in a DataPointModel is not determined. Examples are: + (plus sign) or - (minus sign). ….”. Can have in a hierarchy “*” or “/”? I think: “4.6.2 RuleRelationship … The list of possible signs in a DataPointModel must be “+” or “-“. Examples are: + (plus sign) or - (minus sign). ….”.

[TD] But I think this comment refers to a previous version of the document.

Comment-08

Comment-09

Comment-10

Comment-11

Comment-12

Comment-13

Comment-14

Comment-15

Comment-16

Personal tools